Why Capitalism is way better than any other economic system!

Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
1,709
It's not equal... it's from each according to their ability and to each according to their need. Not everyone has the same levels of ability or needs.

They are not communist, they aren't decentralized and the worker's don't have control over the means of production. You can't have communism with a state.

The system does not encourage laziness because everyone has to contribute to keep it functioning. People have beenworking since before money was ever used... because they needed to. A great incentive to work is need, people need things and we have to work to create them for each other. A person's labor would directly benefit themselves and their community and they know that they are doing their part. Each person is a consumer and a producer. Anarcho-communism is based on mutual aid which is beneficial for both parties because everyone helps each other. Everyone would know and be able to see that their work is directly helping everyone else. People want to do things and not just sit around... if lazy people do arise, other people in the community would deal with them and get them to do something. If the work is important and necessary, then it will be done. Everyone values work that people need. Also with increasing automation, there will be less people having to do the menial labor and more people could focus on their other interests. There isn't that much work to be done in a decentralized society anyway, especially if everyone pitches in and there is automation of a lot of tasks.

How? Since people would have control over their work and would not be subject to state or private authorities, they would have more freedom and not less.
How do you expect that like tomatoes will be grown and shipped? You need these products fast, but the time it takes, makes the system very inefficient. Plus what incentive will they have when they could just keep the tomatoes themselves? There's no money to really provide any incentive to sell or do well.
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
1,709
It's not equal... it's from each according to their ability and to each according to their need. Not everyone has the same levels of ability or needs.

They are not communist, they aren't decentralized and the worker's don't have control over the means of production. You can't have communism with a state.

The system does not encourage laziness because everyone has to contribute to keep it functioning. People have beenworking since before money was ever used... because they needed to. A great incentive to work is need, people need things and we have to work to create them for each other. A person's labor would directly benefit themselves and their community and they know that they are doing their part. Each person is a consumer and a producer. Anarcho-communism is based on mutual aid which is beneficial for both parties because everyone helps each other. Everyone would know and be able to see that their work is directly helping everyone else. People want to do things and not just sit around... if lazy people do arise, other people in the community would deal with them and get them to do something. If the work is important and necessary, then it will be done. Everyone values work that people need. Also with increasing automation, there will be less people having to do the menial labor and more people could focus on their other interests. There isn't that much work to be done in a decentralized society anyway, especially if everyone pitches in and there is automation of a lot of tasks.

How? Since people would have control over their work and would not be subject to state or private authorities, they would have more freedom and not less.
iu.png
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
1,709
It's not equal... it's from each according to their ability and to each according to their need. Not everyone has the same levels of ability or needs.

They are not communist, they aren't decentralized and the worker's don't have control over the means of production. You can't have communism with a state.

The system does not encourage laziness because everyone has to contribute to keep it functioning. People have beenworking since before money was ever used... because they needed to. A great incentive to work is need, people need things and we have to work to create them for each other. A person's labor would directly benefit themselves and their community and they know that they are doing their part. Each person is a consumer and a producer. Anarcho-communism is based on mutual aid which is beneficial for both parties because everyone helps each other. Everyone would know and be able to see that their work is directly helping everyone else. People want to do things and not just sit around... if lazy people do arise, other people in the community would deal with them and get them to do something. If the work is important and necessary, then it will be done. Everyone values work that people need. Also with increasing automation, there will be less people having to do the menial labor and more people could focus on their other interests. There isn't that much work to be done in a decentralized society anyway, especially if everyone pitches in and there is automation of a lot of tasks.

How? Since people would have control over their work and would not be subject to state or private authorities, they would have more freedom and not less.
Plus people can mooch off and take advantage of the system.
 

mecca

Superstar
Joined
Mar 13, 2017
Messages
7,122
Yea it encourages laziness b/c there won't be an incentive to work or provide if they will get equal share. Capitalism provides incentive and competition b/c money can help them get higher and higher up.
Plus people can mooch off and take advantage of the system.
Did you read what I wrote? I addressed this. Also if you want to know more about incentives in an anarcho-communist society, then you should read some books about it.
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
1,709
Did you read what I wrote? I addressed this. Also if you want to know more about incentives in an anarcho-communist society, then you should read some books about it.
Yea I did read it, but some people don't care about others, and will be greedy no matter what
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
1,709
Did you read what I wrote? I addressed this. Also if you want to know more about incentives in an anarcho-communist society, then you should read some books about it.
Yea people worked back then b/c it was necessary. They didn't have industrialization or 1st world wealth. I mean some people still work for MONEY, which will help them get houses and shit. Stuff should not be handed, you SHOULD WORK FOR IT.
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
1,709
Did you read what I wrote? I addressed this. Also if you want to know more about incentives in an anarcho-communist society, then you should read some books about it.
It gives life more meaning. I would feel good for working than just sitting on my ass and being handed everything.
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
1,709
Did you read what I wrote? I addressed this. Also if you want to know more about incentives in an anarcho-communist society, then you should read some books about it.
Plus lets say theres someone that wants to be a vet in a socialist "commune", and there are about 50 others that want to be the same thing. You couldn't have that many in one place. Capitalism also gives competition, to make products better for people. Socialism doesn't do that.
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
1,709
Did you read what I wrote? I addressed this. Also if you want to know more about incentives in an anarcho-communist society, then you should read some books about it.
Ok so to work for providing society. Why the fuck would I do that. Society doesn't give a shit about me.
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
1,709
Did you read what I wrote? I addressed this. Also if you want to know more about incentives in an anarcho-communist society, then you should read some books about it.
See you won't even respond b/c your ideology is so flawed.
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
1,709
Did you read what I wrote? I addressed this. Also if you want to know more about incentives in an anarcho-communist society, then you should read some books about it.
If cooperation is in our nature, why do we love competition so much?
 
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
27
Some of all this discussion might be solved with a flat income tax on individuals and corporations. No deductions. No loopholes (although I'm guess that the larger corporations with literally an army of lawyers would figure out a way). The government is who is taxing the individual and so the tax debate (at least in my mind) really doesn't having anything to do with a capitalistic system. I realize you need to pay some taxes to pay for some needed services, but our government (US) treats the money like it's theirs, except when they spend it -- then they spend it like someone else's money.
 

mecca

Superstar
Joined
Mar 13, 2017
Messages
7,122
There is no such thing as complete equality.
But why can't we strive for a better an more equal society? Of course perfection is unobtainable but that shouldn't be an excuse not to try to get as close to perfect as we can.
 
Top